Money Matters

Why Inflation Makes Holding Cash Risky

Demystifying inflation + how to plan your finances around it.

Have you ever heard a grandparent talk about paying $1 for a king-sized candy bar and thought to yourself,

"Hey that must’ve been nice, nowadays you’ve got to pay like $3 for one of those"

The reason that products were so astoundingly cheap back in the day is that inflation has slowly decreased the purchasing power in the economy. The meta point here is: cash loses value over time and smart investors always plan for how to keep up with inflation.

Demystifying What Inflation Means

Inflation is an economic term that gets thrown around quite often in common conjecture. In simplistic terms:

Inflation is the general rise in the price level in an economy over a given period or the decrease in buying power for a single unit of currency.

  • If inflation has increased in one year, $1 will be less valuable than it was in the previous year.
  • If inflation decreases, then the $1 will be more valuable.

If you've never fully grasped inflation before, these real life examples may help:

Change in cost of goods
In 1990, Mr. Smith went to the grocery store and bought a 20-pack of AA batteries for $5. Out of curiosity, he calculates that $1 buys him four batteries. The man tucks his receipt away, takes the batteries home, and uses them accordingly. Thirty years later, Mr. Smith takes his grandchildren to the store to get a pack of twenty AA batteries. The package of batteries costs him $10, which surprises the man as the price seems higher than he was expecting. Mr. Smith compares his original receipt to his new one and realizes that $1 used to buy him four batteries, and now it only acquires him two batteries. He intelligently deduces that the dollar is now less valuable since it was worth less than thirty years ago.
Scarcity Can Drive Value
John goes to his job as a pawn shop owner, where he finds three guests ready to bid on the two signed movie posters he had been advertising all week. The man sells the first poster for $20 and has only one left. The two bidders who remain climb up to $50 trying to outbid each other for the piece of movie memorabilia. The decrease in the supply of those posters made them much more valuable. Correspondingly, John realizes the opposite is true: when fifty of those posters come in next week, and nobody will pay any more than $5 for them because they're no longer scarce. These two experiences taught the man that items become less valuable when there are more of them available. Therefore, one may conclude that there are more dollar bills in circulation, making them less valuable in trade. This concept is called inflation.

The Situation Today is Scary

The Wall Street Journal says:

"Investors are woefully unprepared for what may be a once-in-a-generation shift in the market".

And they're not wrong. Inflation rates are climbing steadily. In the past, 3-4% of inflation was considered high. Today, we're seeing higher numbers. According to the recently published US Bureau of Labor Statistics Data in October '21:

  • US Inflation Rate is at 9.1%, compared to 1.37% last year.

To understand the full effects of inflation, consider the following example of the purchasing power of $100 in 1971, as compared to today.

  • According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics consumer price index, prices in 2021 are more than 557% higher than prices in 1971.
  • In other words, $100 in 1971 is equivalent in purchasing power to about $657 today.

Cash is no longer king

If you hold cash in a high inflation period, you are passively losing money.

The seven biggest pension fund nations globally, which are the most conservative investment funds, have an average of just 4% cash exposure. Meanwhile, they hold 45% in equities. As an individual you may need more liquidity than this, especially as you near or enter retirement. However, most investment research, like the UBS Investor Watch Survey in 2020, shows the majority of people hold onto too much cash to their own detriment.

Inflation is like a game of musical chairs

To fully grasp why holding cash in a period of high inflation might hurt you, it's important to first review how it affects the economy:

  1. People are less capable of purchasing goods. Why? If inflation causes the dollar to be less valuable and when employers do not raise wages to compensate, people will have less ability to buy goods around them.
  2. More taxes. For example, local governments use taxes to pave roads and build schools. As construction and operating costs become more expensive, the government will adjust fiscal policy to raise tax rates and account for the rising prices.
  3. People tend to stock up. Since inflation often leaves people with less buying power, their marginal propensity to save and stock up on items that lose value slower will increase.
  4. Inflation... causes more inflation. Cash becomes like a hot potato- no one wants it because it's losing value fast. This means people and businesses buy up durable goods, and ultimately: the supply of money outstrips the demand, and the price of money—the purchasing power of currency—falls at an ever-faster rate.

The Federal Reserve can influence the movement of inflation and control its fluctuations with monetary and fiscal policy. The government often has to interfere to avoid hyperinflation, a phenomenon where money devalues so much that people switch to different currencies. In other words - keeping the dollar strong as a currency is usually when the government will step in.

There are different flavors of inflation- learn more here:

When inflation occurs within an economy, the prices of products rise. When these price increases occur rapidly and excessively, the economy will slip into hyperinflation. To be classified as hyperinflation, the average consumer prices must have risen by 50% in a single month.
When an inflation rate remains consistently high for a significant period of time, and unemployment rates do the same, economists are presented with a tricky situation. Suppose they attempt to lower inflation rates (say, by raising taxes and taking money out of circulation). In that case, they may force the unemployment rate to shoot even further (since only certain businesses can survive the temporary tax spike).
As one would imagine, deflation is the antithesis of inflation. Deflationary periods entail value returning to the dollar and prices for consumer goods lowering as a consequence.

What Causes Inflation?

Inflation has many different culprits. If production costs rise, companies will be forced to raise their prices to compensate for the increase in expenses. Production costs can be caused by several factors, such as government intervention on natural resources.

If you want to learn more about inflation, read this example:

A practical explanation of inflation causes:
The government believes that carbon emissions are the primary culprit for rising sea levels. In an attempt to combat this naturally occurring phenomenon, they decide to institute a fee for companies that use more than two CO2 ppm. Ford’s primary manufacturing plant receives news of this new legislation and chooses to raise the prices on their raw material. As a consequence, Ford now pays more for each car to be built and therefore incurs less profit than they did before. However, Ford feels that their profit margins have diminished too much and has decided to raise their car prices as a result. Jenny, a hopeful customer of Ford’s new SUV model, is surprised to see that the price of the vehicle has risen since she initially saw the listing last week. This surprises Jenny greatly and demonstrates that her money is now less valuable in terms of purchasing Ford products. After this experience, Jenny becomes cognizant of the price increases going on everywhere in the consumer market. Namely, she notices the price of gas and groceries rising steadily. Jenny believes that these increases have occurred due to the new legislation, which correspondingly created inflation in her consumer market.

How Investors Manage Inflation

They invest. Investing is essentially shifting your asset holdings from cash to an asset that holds or rises in value faster than inflation.

Take the example of an investor with a $5M portfolio and an annual family expense of $250,000 that is rising by 2% each year due to inflation. What happens if this investor keeps her assets in cash?

It's not pretty.

Keeping the portfolio in cash would halve its value in just 10 years. Any further uptick in inflation would increase the erosion of real purchasing power.

Funds Can Be Stable Investments That Combat Inflation

Historically, market indices such as the S&P 500 have provided steady returns for its investors. Therefore, since the value of this index has consistently risen over time, it competes with inflationary increases as well.

One way to access an index and diversify between a broad number of stocks is through an ETF,or an Extrance Traded Fund. Mutual funds are also popular, but much more expensive since they carry higher management fees.

Consolidate Adjustable- Rate Debt

It may be helpful to consolidate adjustable-rate debt to fixed-rate debt.

Adjustable-rate debt means that the interest rates on loans can fluctuate in accordance with several factors, including inflation. However, fixed-rate debtors can not change their interest rates, which is helpful during inflationary periods.

  • If you owe $500 every year to a creditor and ten years later, the dollar’s value has halved, that means you’re paying $250 at the original value in which you signed the loan.

In other words, fixed-rate debt will decrease as inflation rises.

More Conservative Options, Like CDs

In addition to equities, you can also invest in things like Certificates of Deposit, Treasury Bills (known as T- Bills) and money market accounts. These usually grant you some inflation hedge but their interest rates are below what it takes to counter-act inflation. In most cases, you could still be losing some money by using those as an inflation hedge.

Individual Stocks and Crypto

Investing directly into one or more stocks or buying cryptocurrency is also seen as an inflation hedge. This approach is considered risky for two reasons.

First, high volatility: you'd be susceptible to price movements of an individual asset or small group of assets you can afford to buy. If they don't do well, you could stand to lose part of what you invested originally.

Second: overconfidence bias. Most of us think we know which companies will do well. The truth is, in a period of inflation where the market is experiencing all sorts of constraints, even the most robust businesses will be tested. Not diversifying enough or not building a portfolio with sufficient hedges can significantly hurt your returns over the long run.

Think of Cash Strategically

Even in inflation, there's no possible way to live fully cash-free. At the same time, cash creates a drag on returns so you want to think about it strategically based on your needs.

  1. Emergency and everyday cash: how much do you need for basic life expenses and emergency costs. This money should be easily accessible.
  2. Planned costs over the next 2-5 years
  3. (based on your risk tolerance) Put your cash to work in the markets

3 key takeaways

  • Why is cash bad? At current interest rates, holding excess cash reduces your wealth as inflation erodes its real purchasing power.
  • How much cash do you need? Professional investors typically keep very low cash balances. For some funds, that might be under 4% of their total assets. As an individual, you want to consider having easily accessible cash for emergencies and immediate needs.
  • How should I invest instead? Investors should focus on finding yield and growth opportunities. Equities are the main driver of growth in most portfolios. Picking a ETF or fund is often recommended by most investment advisors because it's best of both worlds : investing in an asset that historically outpaces inflation and getting broad exposure. For example, the average annual return on the MSCI All Country World index since 1998 has been 8% (USD total return), meaning investors have doubled their money roughly every 10 years.

The information provided herein is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to provide tax, legal, or investment advice and should not be construed as an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a recommendation of any security by Candor, its employees and affiliates, or any third-party. Any expressions of opinion or assumptions are for illustrative purposes only and are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results and the opinions presented herein should not be viewed as an indicator of future performance. Investing in securities involves risk. Loss of principal is possible.

Third-party data has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable; however, its accuracy, completeness, or reliability cannot be guaranteed. Candor does not receive compensation to promote or discuss any particular Company; however, Candor, its employees and affiliates, and/or its clients may hold positions in securities of the Companies discussed.